Disclaimer
Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links, which means we may receive a small commission, at no additional cost to you, if you decide to make a purchase through one of our recommended partners. We only recommend products and services we trust and believe will be beneficial to our readers. This helps support our efforts in bringing you valuable content. Thank you for your support.
When you need something sweet
Sometimes you just need something sweet, but when you are watching your health numbers, finding something that will satisfy your sweet tooth and your dietary requirements can be challenging. That’s why this delicious, 4 ingredient dish is so great. It has no added sugar, a small amount of carbs, but a bold sweet taste!
Original Orange “Dream” Smoothie Recipe
Ingredients:
2 medium oranges, any variety, supremed and frozen*
1/2 C milk**
1/4 C plain plain yogurt***
1 T honey
Instructions:
Wash and dry oranges before supreming. Freeze for 2-4 hours
Put frozen orange slices, milk, yogurt and honey into blender, food processor or bullet.
Blend until smooth. Serve immediately or freeze and re-blend just before serving.
Chef Tip:
*Freezing the supremed orange slices replaces having to use ice cubes, which means no diluting of taste.
**Cow’s milk is the type used in the original recipe, but any type of milk, cow, goat, sheep, almond, oat, etc. may be used - realizing the taste will vary depending on your choice of milk.
*** Plain greek yogurt adds a tangy taste, but regular plain yogurt works equally well.
As is, this recipe though delicious, is just a little “quick-burning” due to fruit + honey. A few small tweaks, however, can turn it into a slower burning treat for steadier blood sugar rates while enjoying a treat.
Our Flavor First Refined Recipe
Frozen Orange Cream (Blood Sugar–Friendly Option)
2 medium oranges, supremed & frozen
½ cup milk (or unsweetened almond milk)
¼ cup plain Greek yogurt
1–2 tsp honey (or preferred low-carb sweetener)
Optional: ½ tsp vanilla + pinch cinnamon
Blend until smooth and creamy. Serve immediately for a soft-serve texture or freeze 15–20 minutes for a firmer scoop.
Chef Tip:
1.) Freezing the supremed orange slices replaces having to use ice cubes, which means no diluting of taste.
2.) Using Use Greek yogurt instead of plain yogurt adds protein and a creaminess, but again plain yogurt will work in this recipe.
3.) Optionally adding 1–2 Tbsp protein powder (vanilla works beautifully) slows glucose response and makes it more filling.
4.) Tame the Sweetness without losing the joy by:
Reducing the amount of honey to 1–2 tsp or swapping the honey with:
Monk fruit or stevia blend (zero sugar)
A drizzle of honey at the end instead of blending
You still get sweetness, but with better control
5.) Try adding a Flavor Accent, a:
½ tsp vanilla extract for dessert-like warmth or a
Pinch of cinnamon, enhancing the sweetness naturally or even a
Tiny pinch of salt, making the orange flavor pop!
Nutritional Information:
Original Recipe (with honey, whole milk, regular yogurt)
Per recipe (1 serving):
Calories: ~220–240
Protein: ~7–9g
Fat: ~5–7g
Carbohydrates: ~40–45g
Fiber: ~4–5g
Net Carbs: ~35–40g
Sugar (natural + honey): ~30–35g
Nutritional Information: Improved Flavor First Version (Greek yogurt + reduced honey or substitute)
Per serving:
Calories: ~180–210
Protein: ~12–16g
Fat: ~4–6g
Carbohydrates: ~22–28g
Fiber: ~4–5g
Net Carbs: ~18–24g
Sugar: ~12–18g
Much more balanced for steady energy and blood sugar
Nutritional Highlights
Vitamin C powerhouse from oranges (immune + skin support)
Naturally sweet with minimal added sugar
Probiotics (if using yogurt with live cultures)
Protein boost (when included) helps reduce sugar spikes
Nourish. Move. Thrive.
Subscribe to our FOOD newsletter, Spice & Simmer to get tasty, healthy meal ideas.